Man Booker Longlist 2018/9

Total laptop crash has delayed things somewhat, and I have read quantities of books during the enforced break in communication.

So to the last two Man Booker titles: Normal People by Sally Rooney and Washington Black by Esi Edugyan.

The Sally Rooney novel has had so much publicity and hype that is surely must be on the short list when that is published (20th September), unless the judges are put off by the seeming ubiquity of this novel. I do not read many papers, but it has been all over the ones I do read, so I assume other papers and radio programmes are also bigging-up this book. I have seen some pretty extravagant claims – “JD Salinger for the 21st Century”, for example.

2018 BLL RooneyNormal people is a love story, but with a twist. It is clear to the reader what is going on, but somehow, like ships that pass in the night, Connell and Marianne keep arriving at the same place but slightly at different times. They meet over the course of the book several times, from childhood sharing chocolate spread through to adulthood and new jobs, each time they seem on the brink of getting it together…

Whether or not this is Salinger, it is an interestingly tantalising narrative, plainly spoken. Any novel that covers childhood to adulthood could be described as “a coming of age plot”, this one has been judged highly.

2018 BLL EdugyanWashington Black is of another order entirely for it covers the life story of a black slave who by miraculous means escapes from the island sugar plantation by balloon with his white owner’s brother. His subsequent adventures are also a little short of miraculous. As a slave-to-freedom narrative, this novel has its moments and those are quite graphic and absorbing.

The underground railway features briefly, as do some white people who are odd but good; the bad people are entirely bad and generally white.

I don’t personally find this novel as satisfactory as her previous Man Booker nomination, Half Blood Blues, which I rated very highly. There are other and better slave-to-freedom novels and I just wonder whether it is quite tasteful for anyone, whatever background, to make so little of this transition, in this case through almost magical means.

I think that both of these will make it on to the shortlist, so there is no shadow choice

Advertisements

2 Comments

Filed under Books, History, The Man Booker Prize, Travel, Uncategorized

2 responses to “Man Booker Longlist 2018/9

  1. I liked both of these novels, but Washington Black was my favorite of the two. I love novels about adventures/explorers and this had elements of that, whilst at the same time being very much about a man learning to live with his newfound freedom. I found how he dealt with that very fascinating, especially his attachment to the man who set him free and how he didn’t really stop acting as a slave even when he could. It was a learning curve for him.

    Normal People was a very intense reading experience for me. I was very much in the novel when I read it, but once I was done with it I didn’t really think much more about it.

    My clear favorites this year is The Overstory and The Long Take which are both books that gave me a lot to think about and that were just beautifully written. I’ve yet to read Milkman and The Mars Room, but I doubt they will replace my favorites.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s